Tried and True Chocolate Chip Cookies

October 5, 2019Brianna

Friends, I’ve spent the last 4 months of my life making at least 1 batch of chocolate chip cookies every week. Why? Because I wanted to achieve and have the perfect chocolate chip cookie recipe. Every week I’d read a new food science article and try a new addition or subtraction to the recipe. I feel like I could have won the 4th grade science fair with this science project of mine.

My husband told me I chose the wrong time in life for this project because you cannot buy a normal size bag of chocolate chips here. They are sold in bags that are like half a cup in quantity and are insanely expensive. Think $3 for that tiny bag. You also can’t buy a normal American style brown sugar. The brown sugar here has sugar granules that are very course and big and it is more of a dark brown sugar flavor rather than the traditional light brown sugar most people use in chocolate chip cookies. When I tried to make other cookie recipe with the brown sugar sold here, it did not taste the same. It wasn’t bad, but it didn’t taste the same. So how did I accomplish this task? I literally brought back 2, 50 pound checked bags worth of American baking things and a 35-pound carry-on bag of chocolate chips so they didn’t melt in the suitcase on the airport tarmac in the hot summer weather. I’m telling you, I have been dedicated to this project. This recipe right here is one I hope my great-great-grandchildren will still be making. This is the only chocolate chip cookie recipe you’ll need and this is why I decided this was the recipe worth posting first on my new blog. Please comment and let me know how you liked this recipe and share it with all your friends and family if you loved it!

Print

Tried and True Chocolate Chip Cookies

  • Yield: 3.5 dozen cookies 1x

Ingredients

Scale

1 cup of butter, slightly cold still.

¾ cup white sugar

1 cup packed brown sugar

2 eggs, refrigerated

2 teaspoons vanilla

33 ½ cups flour

¾ teaspoon baking soda

1 teaspoon salt

1 1/2 teaspoon baking powder

2 cups chocolate chips

Instructions

Cream together with a paddle attachment on a stand mixer (or with a hand mixer) the butter and sugars till combined, scraping down the edges as needed. Don’t overmix.

Add the eggs and vanilla and mix till just combined again.

In a separate bowl mix all the dry ingredients minus the chocolate chips together.

Pour the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients and mix till no flour streaks remain. Scrape down the sides as needed. Add the chocolate chips and mix till combined.

Refrigerate at least 30-45 minutes before baking.
To make the “dough cylinders” grab a small fist full of dough and shape into more of a cylinder shape rather than a traditional cookie dough ball. Place the “dough cylinders” on parchment paper or a silipat mat so they’re standing up tall instead of wide. (see pictures for visual)

Bake at 375 F degrees for ~7.5 minutes. Do not overcook.

Remove from baking sheet about 1 minute after they come out of the oven.

Notes

Use slightly chilled butter. Take it out of the fridge 30 minutes before starting or microwave for 15 seconds. Use cold eggs or the cookies dough may need to be in the fridge a bit longer

Don’t over mix your dough or the butter won’t be as cold resulting in flatter cookies.

For my kitchen in Helsinki 3 ¼ cups of flour is perfect. You don’t want the dough to be sticky but too dry is not good either. If you grab a pinch it should not stick to your fingers but should still look wet and not dry. Adding too much flour your cookies will end up more cake-y in the end. Not adding enough flour yields a flatter cookie.

I typically use 1 cup dark chocolate chips and 1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips but this recipe tastes wonderful with any kind of chocolate chips.

Dough cylinders rather than balls will result in a taller cookie with more softness in the middle.

Oven temperatures vary so bake till you can start to see a tiny bit of golden around the bottom edge and very top of your cookie. My oven bakes these cookies perfectly in 7.5 minutes, at sea level.

To achieve the perfect cookie, CHILL YOUR DOUGH. Sorry for yelling, but it yields a more perfect cookie.

I often am a bit impatient in the 30-45 minutes. You can cut the first batch of chilling time down if you make your dough cylinders, place on the tray and refrigerate for 20 minutes. Because they are smaller in size they will chill faster than an entire bowl of cookie dough. By the time the first tray is done baking the rest of your dough will be ready to be formed and go in the oven.

I know most chocolate chip cookie recipes bake at 350 but 375 is magical. It makes the outside of your cookie crisp and perfect but leaving the inside soft and perfect.

If you need instant gratification and can’t wait to bake them and don’t want to chill your dough then bake at 350 for about 8 minutes. (I promise the wait is worth it though to chill!)

4.8 6 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mark Collier
Mark Collier
5 years ago

Followed your recipe and instructions closely. Didn’t know about cold dough and higher heat. Made a big difference as you promised. Love the cookies and the tips!

Ashleigh
Ashleigh
5 years ago

These cookies are amazing! I rarely make cookies because I frequently feel disappointed in how they turn out. I tried this recipe because it PROMISED to be amazing. And believe me, it was! I shared the cookies with visiting family and neighbors and everyone loved them! These are way better than the local cookie chains that keep popping up!

Cathy M
Cathy M
5 years ago

I tried these and they were so good! I’ve been looking for a really good soft chocolate chip cookie recipe. I’ve tried many and this one is my favorite!

Larry
Larry
4 years ago

I love how well these keep. After several days these are still crispy on the outside and soft in the middle. Magic!

Kori
Kori
4 years ago

I made two batches of cookies one with nuts and one with this recipe and the winner was hands down Brianna’s recipe! This is now my go to chocolate chip cookies recipe. Thanks Bri!

Britta B
Britta B
4 years ago

Seriously THE BEST cookie recipe! I’ve made them three or four times now and they have turned out perfect every time. Thanks so much for sharing!

Tiffany Norris
Tiffany Norris
4 years ago

I’ve had a favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe for a decade. I didn’t think it could be beat. But these cookies….are soft but crisp on the outside, perfect balance of sweetness, and they’re even amazing on day 2 and 3! They are the new winner for me.

Lizzy Crowell
Lizzy Crowell
4 years ago

I made these last night and everyone LOVED them! It seems everyone has a different idea of what the perfect chocolate chip cookie is. Well, I think these cookies satisfy EVERYONE! Crispy, chewy, buttery, and oh so good!

Kari
Kari
4 years ago

I love baking cookies and I am always so proud of my cookies, but I have never made a good chocolate chip cookie. Any other flavor I can nail, but the classic chocolate chip is always terrible. This recipe changed everything! For the first time I made perfect chocolate chip cookies. They are crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle – just like I was promised. I was too lazy to make cylinders so I just used my pampered chef cookie scoop, but they were still great! THANK YOU, Bri!!!

Megan Kitchen
Megan Kitchen
4 years ago

These cookies are bomb! I’m very picky about the chocolate chip cookies I choose to put in my mouth. These are the best I’ve ever made, and my previous recipe was pretty darn good. Thank you for this wonderful new staple recipe!

Erin Fuell
Erin Fuell
4 years ago

I followed your recipe exactly, except I used dairy free (avocado oil based) butter and they came out perfectly! They were delicious and stayed soft in the middle.

Jessica
Jessica
4 years ago

I have had a go-to chocolate chip recipe for decades but decided to try this one based on the reviews. I’m so glad I did. THIS RECIPE is SO GOOD! Chocolate chip cookies are best on the first day you make them but these totally were just as good a few days later, not that many made it that long. I can’t believe I’ve never heard of the “cylinder” way of scooping the dough before. GENIUS. I already want to make these again soon.
Do yourself a favor and make these!

Hannah
Hannah
3 years ago

Truly the best chocolate chip cookie recipe I’ve ever used…. TO DIE FOR

Rachel Beenfield
Rachel Beenfield
2 years ago

Yup, yup, and yup! These really are tried and true! My go to chocolate chip cookie recipie for sure! I love how making the dough into the cylinder shape makes the perfect chewy and thicker cookie. Drooling just thinking about these!

Gen
Gen
1 year ago

The most soft gooey cookies ever. These are our go to dessert!

Clarissa
Clarissa
8 months ago

Hands down my favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe. It never disappoints and people love it!

Taylor
Taylor
1 month ago

No joke I have memorized this recipe and make it all the time. These cookies stay soft for days, if they last that long…

Next Post
20
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x